Skip to main content
Symbio search search close

Customer Success | Symbio

Automotive • Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) • Power HIL  • Test Automation • Electronic Control Unit (ECU) • Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle (FCEV)

How Hardware-in-the-Loop Testing Became the Key to Validating Hydrogen Fuel Cells

 

Symbio, whose SymphonHy gigafactory is located in Saint-Fons, near Lyon, France, develops and industrializes hydrogen fuel cell systems; a zero-emission, high-performance, and competitive solution that can electrically power mobility and stationary applications. The company designs and produces four different hydrogen fuel cells called StackPackTM. Fuel cells are electrochemical reactors that use hydrogen—the most abundant element in the universe—and oxygen to generate electricity. Symbio’s product line powers a wide range of on- and off-road fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) and stationary applications.

However, to fulfill its promises, the hydrogen fuel cell must perform as efficiently as possible, and all its components need to work well together. Symbio’s V&V Fuel Cell team, led by Nicolas Deville, ensure that all fuel cell components, such as controllers, converters, and sensors, function safely and seamlessly.

symbio_2_646_513

"Thanks to Speedgoat HIL test system, we are now able to detect bugs earlier. And thanks to power HIL, we can identify issues with components before testing the hydrogen fuel cell as a complete system."

Nicolas Deville, Team Leader, V&V Fuel Cell Team, Symbio

Challenge | Limited Testing Possibilities of Physical Fuel Cells

#

Until a few years ago, only system-level testing was possible, with limitations due to the high costs associated with injecting hydrogen into the fuel cell. As a result, predicting how the fuel cell would deal with faults could not be achieved. 

Nicolas Deville joined the test team at Symbio in spring 2023 after the introduction of the first hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) test system. Two factors seem to have influenced the choice of the test system. On the one hand, engineers from one of Symbio's shareholders were already using Speedgoat test system and recommended it. On the other hand, the software developers at Symbio were working with MATLAB®.

"They made the connection with Speedgoat because they said we could have the full setup, including requirements, software development, and HIL testing with one manufacturer. It would be great if we had the full solution chain," Deville says.

Solution | Automated HIL and Power HIL Testing Guarantee Fuel Cell Component Safety

Deville's test team currently works with three Speedgoat HIL test systems. Compared to the previous setup, they can now test either single or multiple fuel cell components together. "The young engineers in our team can perform everything they want. The setup is versatile. We don't have to develop many tools to do what we want. It's really out-of-the-box from our point of view," Deville explains. The team makes sure each component works properly before carrying out expensive system-level tests.

The team started with a HIL system to test the main electronic control unit (ECU) that controls the chemical reaction of the fuel cells. They modeled sensors, inverters, compressors, and other embedded components to simulate them when testing the ECU. The fuel cell has since received a safety release compatible with open road authorization. "The HIL test system represents now a major activity in open road approval. There is a good level of trust at Symbio and the customer about what we can do with it."

Following the first steps with the HIL setup that still involved manual test work, they introduced the first automated test campaign and soon hit a major milestone within a few months. "Doing something once could be great, but if you performed the same test every week, the manual work could become repetitive," Deville explains. He adds: "The way we can automate testing is a great enabler for us." 

In early 2025, the team started to test compressors, DC-DC converters, and fuel cell monitors (similar to a battery management system) with a power HIL setup. "The purpose of power HIL is to ensure that all components work together at the actual power level before proceeding with the system testing," Deville explains. Currently, they are able to test up to 800 V on the battery side and to simulate fuel cell power behavior at 230 A and 300 V.

Thanks to the power HIL test system, they can now test multiple components thoroughly to ensure that everything runs safely together at actual power levels before the field tests. "Power HIL is the great enabler this year," summarizes Deville. In the future, they want to connect as many components as possible and validate them through simulation as if they were in the vehicle itself.

In addition to HIL and power HIL testings, the Symbio team plans to conduct field test replays, which generate extensive data and help uncover issues requiring control logic updates. "Now we can take this data and replay it directly on the HIL test bench and make sure that the issue will not occur again after the software update."

Result | Developing Fuel Cells Faster with a Trusted Solution

The Speedgoat HIL and power HIL test systems enable Symbio's team to exploit the full potential of component testing and validation, saving time and money. Whenever the software developers add new functions to the control code, Deville's team can report within hours whether the code is working as expected. They can run a campaign with up to 300 tests overnight and analyze the results the next morning. Test automation and a remote connection allow them to use the HIL test system 24 hours, five days a week—a use rate of more than 95%. 

At Symbio, HIL testing has become a must-have to obtain safety approval. The entire development team can now move faster with their projects as well as identify issues at an earlier stage. Deville's team has not missed a deadline so far.

Among all the advantages and benefits they have gained with HIL testing, one aspect stands out: From software developers creating the control code to the system-level tester and the management, everyone places full confidence in the HIL tests. "That's personally my biggest achievement," Deville emphasizes, "to create a solution that everyone trusts."

#

Follow Speedgoat LinkedIn